"[health] is the successful interaction/ relationship which individuals and communities have with their environment."
Salutogenesis and The Sense Of Coherence
Professor Antonovsky was interested in the factors that keep people healthy in difficult to extreme circumstances, and stated that disease and stress occur everywhere, all the time, and yet people can cope well. He was amazed that people who survived the death camps during the Holocaust had the ability to go on to live happy, healthy and productive lives. These horrific experiences did not crush their spirit, and they flourished.
Antonovsky introduced the idea of "the Sense Of Coherence" (SOC) which is the concept of viewing life as:
- comprehensible - the cognitive component,
- manageable - behavioural component and;
- meaningful - the motivational component.
We as human beings have a need to understand each other and to be understood. We need to feel that we can manage situations in life and find the motivation to continue.
Salutogenesis vs Pathogenesis
Health professionals have traditionally been motivated by pathogenesis: the origins and creation of disease. There are significant benefits in a mindset that considers health as "wellness" rather than "illness", through promotion of environments and contexts that encourage wellness. Healthy environments are those that are safe physical environments where there are supportive and respectful relationships among individuals, families and communities.
Professor John Macdonald states in his book "Environments for Health - A Salutogenic Approach" (2005) p.98: "Health is so embedded in the psychological, physical, social, cultural and spiritual environment that one can say: health is environment. Or better: it is the successful interaction/relationship which individuals and communities have with their environment."
A salutogenic view on health is that health is the dynamic and ever-evolving process where we interact positively with our environment, and these positive interactions provide nourishment. A salutogenic engagement with the environment is one where individuals are able to deal well with both negative and positive experiences.
Men and Salutogenesis
Instead of having a deficit view of men, which is very common in western societies, exemplified by phrases such as: 'men don't use health services’, ’men don't seek help’, ’men are violent’, ’men don't talk, or get in touch with their feelings’, a salutogenic approach to men's health is to encourage men's abilities and energetic drive. Maleness should be honoured and encouraged in positive ways. Men engage in positive risk-taking for the benefit of society, and that should be celebrated. In firefighting, for example, 99% of the volunteers are male.
A salutogenic approach to health services and men involves asking the question "to what extent the services are male friendly?, such as:
- out of hours consultations,
- men's health resources and magazines for men in the waiting room,
- a recall system specifically for men's health checks.
Practices that adopt male-friendly approaches can often see an improvement in rates of visitation by men and boys.
Salutogenesis And The Social Determinants Of Health
Creating salutogenic environments forces us to think about the social determinants of health. We need to understand that there are factors in life that impact on the life of men, many of which are out of their control. Simply stating that men need to eat healthier, exercise more or go see the doctor, will not on its own, guarantee health. We need to consider the social determinants of health, where income, stress levels, social gradient, culture and social support/exclusion comes into play and will seriously affect the lives of our men.
Sources: J.J. Macdonald "Environments for Health – a salutogenic approach" (2005), J.J. Macdonald Session 1: Salutogenesis And Salutogenic Environments
- Environments For Health – A Salutogenic Approach (2005) – John Macdonald
Governments and individuals are spending a huge amount of money on health care, curing illnesses, focusing on risk factors and problems rather than prevention, care or maintenance of health. Professor Macdonald urges us to rethink this traditional "acute care" model to foster and promote health instead.
- A Population Health Approach To Men’s Health (2001) – John Macdonald -26 KB
The Fourth National Men’s and Boys’ Health Conference, September 2001. A celebration of all men, and a need to move towards a population health approach that builds on men's strengths and that focuses on creating health strengthening environments and social inclusion for boys and men.
- Shifting Paradigms: A Social-Determinants Approach To Solving Problems In Men’s Health Policy And Practice – John Macdonald
A “social determinants of health” approach to men’s health would help Australia and Australian medical practitioners move away from policies and practices that perpetuate negative views of men and ignore the complexity of their health problems. The result would be a more evidence-based approach to men’s health policy, and the likelihood of improved health outcomes.
What Causes Wellness? Sir Harry Burns, TEDx Glasgow (Youtube video 16.40 minutes)
Sir Harry Burns, professor of global public health at the University of Strathclyde, explores the concept of salutogenesis, the impact the social determinants of health has on the most disadvantaged members of our community, and how feelings of meaning and purpose in life contributes to well-being.
Men's Health Information & Resource Centre
Prof John MacdonaldWestern Sydney University
Locked Bag 1797 Penrith, NSW 2751